Blog

Wine country and the city's wine culture

Napa and Sonoma are a day trip from San Francisco. Here is how California licenses wineries, what counties add, and how the city's own wine trade is regulated.

San Francisco has no vineyards to speak of. What it has is a wine trade: restaurants whose lists are built around bottles grown a short drive north, shops that sell them, and a population that treats a Saturday in Napa or Sonoma as an ordinary weekend plan. The two wine counties lie north of the city, in the North Bay, within about two hours of it, which puts them on the list of day trips from San Francisco. The link runs through the law as well as the map. Every glass poured in the city and every tasting poured in the valleys answers to the same state agency, and the local rules layered on top differ on each side of the bridge.

Why a day trip works

Distance does the explaining. The city sits at the tip of a peninsula, and the routes to the North Bay cross either the Golden Gate Bridge, which opened to vehicles on May 28, 1937, or the Bay Bridge and the East Bay. Drive times vary with traffic and the day of the week, and the live traffic maps at 511.org are the reliable guide. The Golden Gate Bridge on foot and by car describes the bridge's crossing, and Napa and Sonoma in a day covers the trip itself.

The vineyards stock the city's tables. The traffic runs the other way too, more quietly: the compost made from San Francisco's food scraps goes to farms, and the Department of the Environment says those farms include ones that grow fruits, vegetables and grapes for wine. Scraps that leave a San Francisco kitchen can return to the valley as soil. composting: how food scraps leave the kitchen explains the path.

Two bottles, one regulator

California licenses the production and sale of alcohol through its Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, known as ABC. Four of its license types explain most of what a visitor sees:

License What it authorizes
Type 02, winegrower The production and sale of wine by wineries
Type 20, off-sale beer and wine Retail stores selling beer and wine for consumption off the premises
Type 41, on-sale beer and wine, eating place Restaurants serving beer and wine on the premises
Type 47, on-sale general, eating place Restaurants serving beer, wine and spirits on the premises

A winegrower license is the one a winery holds. The state says a winegrower must have facilities and equipment to turn fruit into wine and must actually produce wine. The wine must come from fermented agricultural products, only brandy made from the same product may be used to fortify it, and flavoring or blending material is capped at 15 percent. A winegrower's license carries the privilege of pouring and selling its own wine to the public on the production premises, which is the legal basis of the tasting room.

A retailer or restaurant in the city holds a different license. A shop selling bottles to take home holds an off-sale license, and a restaurant serving them at the table holds an on-sale license (Type 41 for beer and wine, Type 47 for spirits as well). San Francisco adds its own rules on top, including the zoning review, the Police Department's liquor unit and, in crowded areas, the Board of Supervisors' public convenience or necessity finding. last call: how liquor licenses are reviewed explains the city's side.

The winery's extra permits

For events away from the winery building, the state created the Type 93 Estate Tasting Event permit. It is open only to holders of a Type 02 license and lets a winery use its tasting room privileges at an adjacent property it owns or controls, or at a nonadjacent vineyard it owns or controls. Only wine made by or for the winery may be served and sold. The rules are specific:

  • The permit is annual and renews with the master license, and each event needs its own authorization.
  • A winery may hold no more than 36 event days a year.
  • An authorization must be filed at least three days before the event and no more than 90 days before it.
  • Servers and managers must have Responsible Beverage Service certification.
  • ABC's approval does not override local rules. If a city or county agency requires its own approval and does not grant it, the state authorization becomes void and nonrefundable.

That last point is where the two sides of the bridge part ways.

What the counties add

The state decides who may make and sell wine. The counties decide where. Napa County's rules, as law firms that advise wineries describe them, treat tastings as an accessory use to a winery on the same property, so a winery in the unincorporated area can run a tasting room only where it has a winery. A standalone tasting room away from the winery is possible through a duplicate Type 02 license. Sonoma County's treatment of the Type 93 permit, according to the same kind of commentary, allows a Type 02 winery to use its tasting privileges at adjoining or vineyard properties, subject to local approvals.

The pattern is that land use, not licensing, is the county's tool. A county can keep a winery small by controlling what buildings, events and visitor traffic the zoning allows. San Francisco's Planning Department has the same relationship with a bar: the state says a license can be issued, and the city's zoning says whether the corner is the right place.

The 1976 tasting and the 1981 appellation

Two dates explain how a region became a brand. On May 24, 1976, a tasting in Paris organized by Steven Spurrier and Patricia Gallagher compared top California wines with benchmark French bottles. The top-scoring white was a 1973 Chateau Montelena Chardonnay, and the top red a 1973 Stag's Leap Cabernet Sauvignon. The result is known as the Judgment of Paris, and the Napa Valley Vintners' history lists it as a pivotal endorsement of Napa wine.

In 1981 the Napa Valley received its designation as an American Viticultural Area, one of the first in the country. An appellation is a legal definition of a place that a label can claim, and it explains why the word "Napa" on a bottle means grapes from a specific area. The count of nested sub-appellations within Napa Valley has been given as 16 or as 18, depending on the date of the source, a reminder that the map of wine regions is a regulated, changing thing.

Reading a label

The appellation system is the part of wine regulation a shopper meets most often. A label that names an American Viticultural Area, such as the Napa Valley, is making a legal claim about where the grapes grew. Under federal labeling rules, at least 85 percent of the grapes in a bottle labeled with an appellation must come from that area. A label that names only a county or a state is making a broader claim. The name on the front of the bottle can therefore tell a shopper in a San Francisco wine shop something specific about the place, and the retailer who sells it holds the state's off-sale license.

That is also why the vocabulary of wine country turns up on San Francisco menus. A restaurant that lists a wine by appellation is pointing to a regulated place name, and a restaurant that holds a Type 41 or Type 47 license is the legal destination for that bottle.

From grape to glass: a regulated chain

Follow one bottle from the field to a table in the city and count the regulators.

  1. The vineyard sits in a county that controls land use through its zoning and permits.
  2. The winery holds a Type 02 license, which requires that it produce wine and gives it the right to sell it at the production premises. Its tasting room is an accessory use under the county's rules.
  3. The distributor or shipper moves the bottle, and the license types for that step are set by the state.
  4. The retailer or restaurant in San Francisco holds an off-sale or on-sale license, and the city's Planning Department, Police Department and, in some areas, Board of Supervisors reviewed the location before the state issued it.
  5. The server at the table is trained under the state's Responsible Beverage Service rules, which the state requires of servers and managers at winery events and in on-sale establishments.
  6. The leftovers go in the green bin, travel to a composting site in the Central Valley, and become compost sold to farms.

No single office sees the whole chain, which is why each step has its own page and its own phone number.

What a winery visit looks like legally

A visitor in a tasting room is part of a transaction the law describes narrowly. The winery is pouring its own wine under its winegrower license. If the winery holds a special tasting event at a vineyard it owns, away from the winery building, it needs the Type 93 permit and an authorization for each event day. If the winery wants to open a tasting room in a downtown away from the vineyard, Napa County's rules point to a duplicate Type 02 license rather than a standard tasting-room permit. For visitors the practical effect is simple: a winery can pour only wine that it made or that was made for it at an event under a Type 93, and a tasting room is a place where that rule applies.

The city's own wine culture

San Francisco plays the market and the showcase. Restaurants hold the on-sale licenses that let them pour wine. Wine merchants hold the off-sale licenses that let them sell it to take home. The state's rules apply everywhere, and the city's rules shape where on the map a restaurant or shop can open.

The city's calendar also includes events that involve wine and food in public settings. San Francisco month by month lists the year's main events and seasons. Anyone who wants to host an event that pours wine needs both the state's authorization and the city's permits for the event, and the sequence is explained in How a street fair or block party gets permitted in San Francisco.

Practical notes for a visit

  1. Plan transportation first. A tasting trip involves alcohol and a long drive. Rideshare, a hired driver or a group tour are the usual answers, and the 511 service lists the transit options.
  2. Check each winery's visiting policy. A winery's own website states whether it takes walk-ins or asks for reservations.
  3. Check the date. Harvest, the season of picking and crushing, changes the pace at wineries, and the weather on the north side of the bay differs from the fog on the city's western edge. fog and the city's microclimates explains why the city's weather is so local.
  4. Ask about licensing if you host. A winery that offers events off its main site must have the Type 93 permit and local approval.

The state's ABC site at abc.ca.gov lists every license type in plain language, and the counties' planning departments post the rules for tasting rooms and events.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic