Blog

Who appoints San Francisco's commissions

The charter's four ways of filling city commissions, which bodies use each, and how a mayoral appointment can be rejected by eight supervisors.

A lot of San Francisco's weightiest decisions never reach the mayor or the Board of Supervisors. Seven people sit on the Police Commission. A board of directors answers for Muni. Other commissioners oversee the Port and the Public Utilities Commission. Who gets those seats, and who can say no, shapes how city departments are run. The City Attorney's Good Government Guide sorts the charter's rules into four methods, and the differences between them are more than technical.

What follows compares the four, names the bodies that use each, and lays out the rules that apply to all.

Method 1: the mayor appoints, the Board can reject

The most common method comes from Charter Section 3.100(18). The mayor appoints every member of the commission. The appointment takes effect when the mayor sends a Notice of Appointment to the Clerk of the Board of Supervisors, and the notice has to include the person's qualifications and a statement of how the person represents the communities of interest, neighborhoods and diverse populations of the city.

The Board does not vote to confirm. It can only say no, and it has to do so by a two-thirds vote, eight of eleven members, within 30 days after the Notice of Appointment is sent. If eight votes are not found within 30 days, the appointment stands.

The bodies that follow this rule include:

  • Airport Commission
  • Arts Commission
  • Civil Service Commission
  • Commission on the Environment
  • Commission on the Status of Women
  • Disability and Aging Services Commission
  • Fire Commission
  • Health Commission
  • Human Rights Commission
  • Human Services Commission
  • Juvenile Probation Commission
  • Library Commission
  • Recreation and Park Commission
  • War Memorial Board of Trustees

Boards and commissions created by ordinance that wield executive power must also be appointed this way.

Method 2: the mayor appoints, with different approval rules

A variant leaves the appointments entirely in the mayor's hands but changes when they take effect. In some cases an appointment is not effective until the Board approves it. In others it becomes effective after a set number of days unless the Board disapproves. This method covers four powerful bodies:

  • Historic Preservation Commission
  • Municipal Transportation Agency Board of Directors, which governs Muni and the city's parking and traffic functions
  • Port Commission
  • Public Utilities Commission

The Municipal Transportation Agency, the Port and the Public Utilities Commission oversee enterprise departments that earn their own revenue. For the MTA, the agency's board is appointed by the mayor and confirmed by the Board of Supervisors. See San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency for the agency itself.

Method 3: shared between the mayor and the Board

Some commissions have members chosen by both the mayor and the Board of Supervisors (or the Board president). The details vary body by body: some appointments by the mayor are subject to the Board's review or approval, others are not. The bodies in this group include:

  • Board of Appeals
  • Building Inspection Commission
  • Entertainment Commission
  • Homelessness Oversight Commission
  • Planning Commission
  • Police Commission
  • Sheriff's Department Oversight Board
  • Small Business Commission
  • Youth Commission

The Police Commission shows how this looks in practice. Its seven members are appointed by the mayor and the Board of Supervisors, and it meets Wednesdays at 5:30 p.m. It sets policy for the Police Department and holds disciplinary hearings on misconduct charges, including officer appeals from discipline imposed by the chief. The Sheriff's Department Oversight Board, created by voters in 2020, is similarly appointed by the mayor and the Board. See filing a complaint about police services and The Sheriff's Office and the bodies that oversee it.

The logic of Method 3 is checks and balances inside a single commission: a body that oversees the police, or that decides land use appeals, has members who owe their seats to more than one elected official.

Method 4: several appointing authorities

The fourth method spreads appointments beyond the mayor and the Board entirely. The bodies include:

  • Elections Commission. Seven members: the mayor, the Board of Education, the Board of Supervisors, the City Attorney, the District Attorney, the Public Defender and the Treasurer each appoint one. The commission oversees public elections and sets general policy for the Department of Elections, and it can remove the Director of Elections only for cause after the probation period. See San Francisco Department of Elections.
  • Ethics Commission. Five members: the mayor, the Assessor, the Board of Supervisors, the City Attorney and the District Attorney each appoint one. With five appointing authorities, no single official controls the body that administers the city's campaign finance and ethics laws. See Campaign money and the Ethics Commission.
  • Health Service Board. Two mayoral appointees, a supervisor named by the Board president, an appointee of the Controller and three members elected by participants in the Health Service System.
  • Retirement Board. Three mayoral appointees, a supervisor named by the Board president and three members elected by participants in the Retirement System.
  • Retiree Health Trust Fund Board. One appointee each of the Controller, the Treasurer and the executive director of the retirement system, plus two members elected by participants in the Health Service System.
  • Public Works Commission and Sanitation and Streets Commission. Each has two members appointed by the Board of Supervisors, two appointed by the mayor subject to Board confirmation, and one appointed by the Controller subject to Board confirmation.

A few bodies fit none of the four patterns. The Fine Arts Museums Board of Trustees, for example, is self-perpetuating: the sitting trustees elect new ones.

Rules that apply to nearly all of them

Whatever the method, the Good Government Guide sets common rules for commissioners of charter bodies.

Residency and age. Members of charter commissions must be residents of the city and of legal voting age, and must stay so during their tenure. A few bodies are exempt (the Youth Commission, the Asian Art Commission and the Fine Arts Museums trustees), and ordinance-created bodies can waive the rules when no qualified willing person can be found. A commissioner who stops meeting the requirements has effectively resigned by operation of law.

Terms. Most appointive commissions have four-year terms, staggered when the body is created. An incumbent whose term has ended can usually stay on as a holdover, but the charter generally limits that to 60 days. Some bodies, the Police Commission among them, allow no holdovers at all, so terms end on the date they end. The term runs with the seat, not the person: someone appointed to a seat that has been vacant for six months serves only the remainder of that term.

Oath and status. A commissioner of a body that exercises sovereign power must take the oath of office before acting, and once sworn becomes an officer of the city. The guide describes the office as a public trust and says commissioners owe a duty of loyalty to the whole city, even those chosen to bring a specific neighborhood or professional view.

Disclosure. If the position requires filing a Statement of Economic Interests, the appointing authority has to tell the Ethics Commission the appointee's name within 15 days of the person taking office.

Pay. The Board of Supervisors sets compensation, if any, for each board or commission, unless the charter says otherwise.

Attendance. The charter generally sets no specific attendance requirement, but repeated absences by commissioners who can be removed only for cause can be official misconduct and can support removal.

A mayoral appointment from start to finish

To watch Method 1 run on a calendar, take a hypothetical seat on the Library Commission (a body the guide lists under Section 3.100(18)). The dates are invented; the clocks are the charter's.

  1. Day 0. The mayor signs a Notice of Appointment naming a resident and sends it to the Clerk of the Board. The notice states the person's qualifications and how the person represents the communities of interest, neighborhoods and diverse populations of the city. The appointment takes effect on transmittal.
  2. Days 1 to 30. The Board of Supervisors can reject the appointment, but only with eight votes. A resolution to that effect would have to be introduced and passed inside this window. If no such vote happens, nothing further is needed.
  3. Before acting. The new commissioner takes the oath of office required by the California Constitution and becomes an officer of the city.
  4. Within 15 days of taking office. If the seat requires a Statement of Economic Interests, the mayor's office tells the Ethics Commission the appointee's name.
  5. Four years. The term runs from a fixed anniversary date, not from the day this person was sworn in. If the seat was vacant for months, the new member serves the rest of the term, not a full four years.
  6. After the term. If no successor has been named, the commissioner can hold over for 60 days at most.

Compare Method 3. If the same hypothetical seat were on the Planning Commission, the mayor and the Board would each hold some of the appointments.

Questions people ask

Does the Board of Supervisors confirm the mayor's commission picks? For most commissions it does not vote to confirm. It can reject a Method 1 appointment with eight votes in 30 days. Confirmation votes apply in specific cases: the Municipal Transportation Agency board, for example, is confirmed by the Board.

Can a commissioner be fired? Under the rules in force in mid-November 2026, appointed members can usually be suspended or removed only if the member engaged in official misconduct or committed certain felonies, as the Ballot Simplification Council's digest in the November voter pamphlet describes it. A November ballot measure, discussed below, would change that. The Elections Commission can remove the Director of Elections only for cause after probation.

Do commissioners have to live in San Francisco? Yes for charter bodies, with a few named exceptions.

Do commissioners get paid? Only if the Board of Supervisors sets compensation for that body.

Department heads, removal and the November 3 ballot

Who appoints the commissioners is half the picture. The other half is who picks the department heads they oversee and who can remove either. The Ballot Simplification Council's digest for Proposition F, a charter amendment on the November 3, 2026 ballot, describes the rules as they stand in mid-November:

  • The mayor is the chief executive and directly supervises nearly 50 city departments, most of them created by the charter.
  • Department heads. In most cases the mayor must select a department head from candidates recommended by the board or commission that oversees the department. Usually the board or commission can fire the department head, but the mayor cannot.
  • Transfers. The mayor can transfer responsibilities between departments created by ordinance, as long as the Board of Supervisors does not object, but cannot transfer responsibilities of departments created by the charter.
  • Deputy mayors. The mayor cannot hire deputy mayors to supervise most charter departments.
  • Commissioners. Appointed members can usually be suspended or removed only for official misconduct or certain felonies.

Proposition F would amend the charter to expand the mayor's authority to transfer responsibilities between departments, hire deputy mayors and hire some and fire most department heads, and to allow the officials who appoint board and commission members to remove them at any time without cause. The digest lists exceptions: the Board of Appeals, the Civil Service Commission and the Ethics Commission members would keep their protection, and departments such as the Controller, the Port, the Department of Police Accountability, the Department of Elections, the Ethics Commission, the Sheriff's Inspector General and the City Administrator would be exempt from the mayor's new hiring and firing authority. The Controller's statement says the measure would have a minimal cost, apart from deputy mayors at roughly $250,000 a year each. The petition for Proposition F was certified as qualified on July 23, 2026.

Proposition A, which the Board placed on the same ballot by a 9 to 2 vote on July 14, 2026, would also reshape the picture. It would align the charter with how some departments operate and eliminate or reorganize certain commissions and advisory bodies, moving some from the charter into the Municipal Code, and the Controller estimated savings of $365,000 to $450,000 a year. The Controller's statement names the Sanitation and Streets Commission, the Public Works Commission and the Street Artists and Craftsmen Examiners Advisory Committee in describing those savings.

Results of the November 3 election were still being counted in mid-November 2026, and this piece states none. Everything above describes the rules before any approved measure takes effect; the Department of Elections and the City Attorney's Office publish the official outcome. how a charter amendment reaches the ballot explains how measures like these reached the ballot.

Why the differences matter

The four methods hand different people different leverage. Under Method 1 the mayor has nearly total control, with a high bar of eight votes for the Board to intervene. Under Method 3 the Board has a direct seat at the table. Under Method 4 neither may dominate. When a policy dispute turns on who controls a body, the appointment method is usually the first thing to check. The Controller's Office page also lists the final recommendations of a Commission Streamlining Task Force, published in January 2026.

For a resident who wants to serve, the route starts with the mayor's appointment application and the Board's vacancy notices, described in Applying for a mayoral appointment to a San Francisco board or commission. For the basics of how the Board works with all of these bodies, the eleven districts and what a supervisor does explains the non-interference rule, and the Board's own about page is a good starting point.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic