Blog
The Tenderloin, block by block
A walk through the Tenderloin's fifty flat blocks between Union Square and Civic Center: its grid, its housing, its immigrant history and its landmarks.
Most of San Francisco is a place where a street climbs a hill, goes over and drops down the other side. The Tenderloin is the exception: about fifty flat blocks on the southern slope of Nob Hill, between Union Square and Civic Center, laid out in a tight grid with very few trees and a great many people per block. Historically it is bounded by Geary Street on the north, Mason Street on the east, Market Street on the south and Van Ness Avenue on the west. All of it fits in about 0.35 square miles.
The neighborhood usually comes up in talk about the city's problems. This walk takes it as a neighborhood instead, with the history, buildings and institutions that fill its blocks, and leaves out the statistics that dominate the news.
The name and where it came from
The name most likely traveled from an older Tenderloin district in Manhattan. One account credits a New York police captain, Alexander S. Williams, with bringing the term west, though the origin of the name is not firmly settled. San Francisco maps did not carry it until the 1930s, though people used it informally as early as the 1890s.
The district has been a downtown residential community since shortly after the 1849 Gold Rush. By the late nineteenth century it had theaters, restaurants and hotels. The 1906 earthquake and the fires set to contain it destroyed almost all of its buildings, and the rebuilding was fast: hotels opened by 1907 and apartment buildings followed (the 1906 earthquake and fire). The Cort Theatre opened in 1911, and the San Francisco Symphony played its first concert there that December. In the 1920s the area was known for gambling, speakeasies and theaters, and it turns up in the detective fiction of Dashiell Hammett.
The buildings
What strikes you first about the Tenderloin's architecture is how much of it is the same age. The blocks went up again in a short stretch after 1906, so the district is a collection of apartment hotels and residential buildings in related styles, with storefronts on the ground floor. In July 2008 the Uptown Tenderloin Historic District was listed on the National Register of Historic Places, in recognition of the architecture of that rebuilding.
Much of the housing is single-room-occupancy (SRO) hotel rooms, studios and one-bedroom apartments. Many of the SROs are owned by nonprofits. That, along with zoning limits on high-rises and historic protections, has held redevelopment back, and the neighborhood has kept the scale it had a century ago.
What an SRO is
A single-room-occupancy hotel is a building divided into small rooms rented one at a time, often by the month, with bathrooms or kitchens shared down the hall. They were built to house workers and travelers, and in the Tenderloin they became a permanent form of housing for people who could not afford an apartment. A room in a building like this can be one person's home for years.
That is why the nonprofit ownership matters. When a nonprofit housing organization owns the building, the rooms stay in the housing supply for tenants with low incomes rather than being converted to other uses. The limits on high-rise construction and the neighborhood's historic protections work the same way: they slow the kind of redevelopment that changed the neighborhoods around it.
People who came
The Tenderloin has always taken in newcomers. Starting in the late 1970s the neighborhood absorbed large numbers of refugees from Southeast Asia, including ethnic Chinese from Vietnam and Khmer and Hmong refugees from Cambodia and Laos. More recently there have been immigrants from Latin America. A stretch of Larkin and Hyde Streets between Turk and O'Farrell has been officially named Little Saigon by the city.
For a downtown district, it has an unusually high number of children. One count put it at about 3,000, mostly in immigrant families. That shapes what the Tenderloin needs: playgrounds, schools, afterschool programs and clean sidewalks as much as services for adults. Boeddeker Park, at Eddy and Jones Streets, is among the most heavily used parks per square foot in the city. Its renovation was completed in December 2014. The Recreation and Park Department has more on the park (San Francisco Recreation and Park Department).
A walk, block by block
This route hits the main points in about an hour. It is flat all the way.
1. Start at Powell and Market. The Powell Street BART and Muni Metro station is at the southern edge of the neighborhood, and the Civic Center/UN Plaza station is at the western edge. From either, walk north into the grid (Tenderloin).
2. Walk up Taylor or Jones Street. The cross streets run through the heart of the district. Look at the ground floors: small markets, restaurants, laundromats and corner stores, each serving the people in the buildings above.
3. Turk and Taylor Streets. In 1966, at a cafeteria at this intersection, the Compton's Cafeteria riot broke out after police tried to arrest a drag queen. It is counted among the early gay riots, predating Stonewall by three years. In 2017 part of the neighborhood was declared the Compton's Transgender Cultural District.
4. Larkin and Hyde, between Turk and O'Farrell. This is Little Saigon. Read the signs, the shops and the restaurants and you will see the Vietnamese community that has been part of the neighborhood for decades.
5. Eddy and Jones: Boeddeker Park. Sit a few minutes. The park is a good place to see who lives in the neighborhood: parents with young children, older residents and people who work nearby.
6. Glide Memorial Church. The church, in the neighborhood, was reinvigorated in 1963 and provides meals and social services. It is one of the best-known institutions in the Tenderloin.
7. Finish at Civic Center. From the western edge of the neighborhood, Civic Center is a few blocks away (A walk around Civic Center).
Why the grid is flat
San Francisco's famous hills are not everywhere, and the Tenderloin sits in a low place between them. Nob Hill rises on its northern edge; Civic Center and Market Street are on level ground to the south and west. The flatness made the area easy to subdivide and rebuild quickly, and it is why the district was an obvious place for hotels and theaters when downtown expanded west after the Gold Rush. It also makes this the easiest walk between Union Square and the city's government buildings.
The weather is the downtown weather. The NOAA normals for the downtown station put average highs in the high 50s in winter and about 70 degrees in September, with the wet season from roughly November through April and the heaviest rain in December and January. Sidewalks are busy in every season, and in the wet months this is a good district for walking quickly between the Powell and Civic Center stations.
Getting around
The Tenderloin sits between two of the city's busiest transit nodes. BART and Muni Metro run under Market Street at the Powell Street and Civic Center/UN Plaza stations, and several Muni bus routes, including the 19 Polk and the 38 Geary, run through or along the district (How to ride Muni). The Stockton Street Tunnel connects the neighborhood to Chinatown.
Because the streets are flat, the Tenderloin is one of the easier parts of downtown to walk, and it is a common route between Union Square and Civic Center.
Services and city government
The neighborhood also houses several city offices. The Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing is at 440 Turk Street, and the Department of Public Health is at 1145 Market Street, at the neighborhood's southern edge (San Francisco Department of Public Health). City services in the Tenderloin are reached the way they are everywhere in San Francisco: 311 takes reports of street and sidewalk problems, and handles requests for cleaning, graffiti removal and repairs (Using 311 in San Francisco, by phone, app or web). The sf.gov data pages include a data story on cleaner sidewalks and streets in the Tenderloin, which describes the city's approach to the work and the results it has tracked (open data and the city's performance scorecards).
Things people get wrong
- That it is a single thing. The Tenderloin is residential, commercial and institutional, with families, older residents, workers, artists and people passing through. It is also part of the theater and nightlife history of the city.
- That it is separate from downtown. It sits between Union Square and Civic Center, within walking distance of both, and its edges touch the city's main shopping and government districts.
- That it has no open space. It has Boeddeker Park, and the nearby Civic Center plazas and Union Square are a walk away.
- That nothing changes. The neighborhood's population, its housing and its streets have changed with every decade since the Gold Rush: after the fire, after World War II when the population declined and many housing units were vacant by the mid-1970s, after the refugee arrivals of the late 1970s.
Reading the neighborhood
The Tenderloin is easy to see badly and hard to see well. A walker who goes in expecting nothing but the city's problems will find them. A walker who goes in looking at the buildings, the signs in several languages, the church, the park and the people who live above the shops will see a dense downtown neighborhood that has done what neighborhoods do: take in newcomers, house them and give them a place to start.
For a different view of the same city, walk next to Civic Center, where the buildings are monumental rather than domestic, and the neighborhood's western edge meets the city's governing district.