Blog
Dungeness crab and the waterfront
The Pacific crab behind a San Francisco tradition: how the fishery works, why the season shifts, and how the Port lets boats sell crab at Fisherman's Wharf.
Around here the opening of the commercial crab season gets treated like a minor holiday, and has for as long as anyone can remember. At the center of the fuss is the Dungeness crab, Metacarcinus magister, the large, sweet-fleshed crab of the Pacific coast that has long been bound up with San Francisco's waterfront. It is the crab in the cioppino pot (see Cioppino, a San Francisco fish stew), the crab on the sidewalk stands at Fisherman's Wharf and, since a Port program changed the rules, a crab you can buy straight off the boat that caught it.
The animal and its range
The Dungeness crab lives along the Pacific coast from the Aleutian Islands of Alaska south to Point Conception, near Santa Barbara, with occasional crabs found farther south. It is caught mostly in wire pots, baited in the center and fitted with one-way door flaps, and each pot is tied by a line to a small buoy. They are typically set in 60 to 300 feet of water. Rules require a biodegradable rot cord on each pot, so a lost pot will not keep trapping crabs indefinitely.
San Francisco has a claim to a founding role. The fishery is dated to 1848, when San Francisco fishermen started it. For more than a century and a half the crab has been caught off the coast and landed in ports along it, the city's own among them.
The rules that shape the season
Dungeness crab fishing is managed to keep the population healthy, and a few rules explain why the crab you eat is what it is.
- Males only. California's commercial harvest is limited to male crabs.
- A size minimum. The commercial minimum is 6.25 inches across the shell in California, which lets crabs mature before they are taken. The recreational minimum is slightly lower, at 5.75 inches.
- Escape rings. Pots carry escape rings of at least 4.5 inches, so undersized crabs can leave.
- A season. The season generally opens in November or December and runs until late summer, closing in the fall to protect soft-shelled crabs. Exact dates are set each year.
Those rules are why fishery managers consider the crab population stable. Catch has been steady for more than thirty years, according to fishery studies, which cite it as evidence that the stock is not overfished. Since 1970, the fishery has taken between 9 and 98 percent of legal males in a given season, averaging about 66 percent, and most of the catch comes in the first six weeks.
That last fact explains the excitement at the start of the season. A large part of the year's crab arrives in the first weeks, and opening day is the moment of greatest supply and, often, of the most attention.
Why the opening day moves
The opening is not fixed, and in some years it is delayed. The most common cause is a harmful algal bloom. Toxic blooms can leave crabs with elevated levels of domoic acid, a natural toxin, and state officials can hold the opening or close parts of the coast until testing shows the crab are safe. The 2016 season, for example, was delayed by toxic algal blooms. The state's fish and wildlife and public health agencies set the dates, and the city does not.
For a shopper in San Francisco, the upshot is that crab supply can vary from year to year. A late opening or a closed stretch of coast means fewer crabs at the docks and in the markets. The Port's program, described below, is one place where that variation shows up directly.
The fleet at Fisherman's Wharf
The commercial fishing boats that supply the city berth at the working harbor of Fisherman's Wharf, on the northern waterfront (see Fisherman's Wharf). Visitors know the wharf best for its piers, shops and sea lions, but it remains a working harbor, and the boats are the reason.
Crab has long been sold there the familiar way, from sidewalk stands where crabs are cooked in big pots and served to people on foot. The Port's retail fish program was designed to add a second path for sales without displacing the first: it lets fishers sell directly from their boats.
How the Port's retail fish program works
The Port of San Francisco, which owns and manages the waterfront (see Port of San Francisco), has run an off-the-boat retail fish sales program at Fisherman's Wharf, and the program has a short history.
- Earlier version, 1999 to 2000: A first version let commercial fishing boats at the wharf's harbor sell fish retail from their berths directly to consumers.
- 2017: The Port Commission authorized a new off-the-boat retail fish sales pilot program, aimed at widening commercial opportunities for fishers and giving customers a more direct experience at the wharf.
- Crab added later: Crab was at first excluded, to avoid unnecessary competition with the existing crab stands. Live Dungeness crab sales were later added as a one-year pilot, and then staff recommended making them permanent. The Port began allowing live Dungeness crab sales directly from fishing vessels when the commercial crab season opened, on December 29.
The program's rules, as the Port describes them, are straightforward:
- Sales happen from the vessel. Fish and crab must be sold from the boat, during daylight hours, and customers are not allowed on board.
- Only local boats take part. Transient boats are not allowed to participate.
- Fish and crab are sold whole and uncooked. Fish must be sold gilled and gutted only, to follow the Health Code. Crab is sold live.
- Boat operators must be permitted. Permits are issued annually, and the Port's program has required a state commercial fisherman's retail license, a San Francisco weights and measures seal and a business registration certificate.
Those requirements show how the program fits into the city's regulation of food. The state licenses the fisher, the city's weights-and-measures program certifies the scale, the Treasurer registers the business and the Port grants the berth and the permit (see San Francisco Department of Public Health for the health side of food regulation in the city).
Where and when to buy
The Port's page says the retail pier is on Al Scoma Way, behind the Jefferson Street businesses at Fisherman's Wharf. A few details from the Port's guidance for buyers:
- Check before you go. Sale times are not fixed. The fishers post updates through their own social media accounts, and sales depend on weather and availability. Boats can sell out.
- Arrive early. Lines are common.
- Bring a cooler or bucket. You carry the crab or fish away yourself.
- Cash is preferred. Some fishers accept electronic payments.
- Do not park on Al Scoma Way. Nearby off-street and metered parking is available.
The program lists seasonal availability, which gives a picture of the wharf's year. Rock cod and lingcod are sold through the year as bycatch. Dungeness crab is available from December to June. California halibut is available from April to November, Chinook salmon from May to October, live coonstripe shrimp from May to October and albacore tuna from August to October. Live anchovies and sardines, sold as bait, are available in summer.
Crab on the menu and in the market
Crab that does not go through the Port's program reaches buyers by other routes: wholesalers, markets and restaurants. The city's food-safety rules apply to all of them. Health permits for restaurants and markets are issued by the Department of Public Health's Environmental Health Branch (see how food trucks and carts get permitted for one slice of that system).
In the kitchen, crab is prepared a few ways. Boiled or steamed, it is served cracked, with butter or a dipping sauce. In stews such as cioppino, it simmers with tomato and wine. At the wharf's stands, it is cooked in large pots outdoors, in a long-running spectacle of steam and noise. Dish and boat are connected by the same animal, and the crab's season shapes the menu.
What the crab shows about the waterfront
The Dungeness crab is a useful lens on the city's relationship with its harbor. It shows that:
- The waterfront is still a working one. The boats at Fisherman's Wharf are commercial fishing vessels, and the Port's program supports their sales.
- The city shares authority. The state sets seasons and sizes, the Port manages the wharf, and the city's other agencies regulate sales and food safety.
- The season is tied to nature. Algal blooms, ocean conditions and the crabs' own life cycle shape when and how much the fleet can catch.
- The old and the new coexist. Sidewalk stands, boat sales and restaurants all sell the same crab, each in its own way.
The Port also plans for the future of the waterfront under its Waterfront Resilience Program, which addresses sea-level rise, and that planning will affect the piers and harbor where the fishing fleet works.
Reading the weights and prices
One detail of buying crab at the wharf or in a market is the price by weight. A crab is sold live and priced per pound, and the scale it is weighed on must be certified, which is why a San Francisco weights and measures seal appears among the program's requirements. A buyer who wants to compare, say, two crabs of different sizes can do the arithmetic simply: a crab weighing two pounds at a posted price of a given amount per pound costs twice that amount, and a crab that looks like a bargain by the piece may not be one by the pound. The same principle applies to fish sold whole, where the gilled and gutted weight is what the scale shows. Prices move with the season, the size of the catch and the demand, so the number posted that day is the one that counts.
A short calendar
- November or December: The commercial season generally opens, subject to testing. In the Port's program, live crab sales from boats run from December.
- December to June: Dungeness crab is available through the retail program.
- Late summer: The commercial season is generally over, and crabbing closes in the fall to protect soft-shelled crabs.
For current dates, the state's fish and wildlife agency announces openings, and the Port's off-the-boat sales page lists the program's rules and seasons. The Port's page and the fishers' own updates are the best guide to what is on the pier the day you visit.