Blog
The Palace of Fine Arts, built to last
Maybeck's temporary 1915 ruin, why it was rebuilt in concrete from 1964, and why it is the one exposition building still standing on its original site.
It looks as if it has stood there since antiquity: a rotunda on a still lagoon, a curving colonnade, stone that seems to have weathered a few centuries. None of that is true. The Palace of Fine Arts was drawn in 1915 as a temporary building for a world's fair, made of wood, plaster and fiber, and expected to vanish. It became the only exposition building to survive on its original site, and then, when the original rotted away, it was torn down in 1964 and built again in concrete. The Palace in the Marina today is a copy of itself, which is exactly why it is still there.
A quiet place at a loud fair
The Panama-Pacific International Exposition of 1915 was San Francisco's celebration of the Panama Canal and of its own recovery from the 1906 earthquake and fire (The Panama-Pacific International Exposition, 1915). It covered a stretch of the northern waterfront with palaces, courts and amusements, and over its run it drew more than 18 million visitors. It closed on December 4, 1915.
Bernard Maybeck, a Bay Area architect, was asked to design the building that held the fair's fine art. He did not think of it as a palace in the usual sense. He wanted a quiet passage between the crowded fairgrounds and the art exhibits, a place to slow down before going in. He drew on two sources. One was Roman ruins, with their broken colonnades and ivy. The other was a painting by the Swiss artist Arnold Böcklin, Isle of the Dead, whose island of cypresses and funerary architecture appealed to the architect as a mood. The result was a rotunda beside a small artificial lagoon, with colonnades that separated the water from the exhibition hall behind. Figures of weeping women, sculpted by Ulric Ellerhusen, top the colonnade. The building is now listed on the National Register of Historic Places and is a designated San Francisco landmark.
Built of staff
The material was part of the design. Most buildings at the fair were framed in wood and covered with staff, a mixture of plaster and fiber that could be molded into columns, cornices and sculpture and painted to pass for travertine or marble. Chicken wire and plaster stood in for stone. The method was fast and cheap, and it let architects raise whole classical cities in a few months. It also meant the buildings were never meant to last. Staff crumbles in rain and wind, and when the fair ended most of the structures were pulled down.
The fates of the others make a useful contrast. The French Pavilion was demolished, and the Spreckels family later gave San Francisco a replica of it, which became the Legion of Honor (The de Young and the Legion of Honor). The Tower of Jewels was taken apart and sold off to scavengers. The Palace of Fine Arts was supposed to go the same way.
The first rescue
It did not, because people had come to love it. While the fair was still running, Phoebe Apperson Hearst founded a Palace Preservation League to save it. After the fair, several of San Francisco's preservation groups joined in. They kept the building standing, but a structure of wood and plaster was always in decline. The staff covering cracked, the wood frame rotted and the building grew steadily less safe. By the early 1960s it had deteriorated so badly that the question was no longer whether to repair it but whether to keep it at all.
The other survivors, and the copies
The Palace was not the only piece of the fair to outlive it, though it was the only major building to stay on its original ground. The National Park Service's account of the exposition's legacy lists several others.
- The Oregon Building was kept by the Army at the Presidio as a military clubhouse, and the Ohio Building was moved by barge to Belmont, in San Mateo County. Marin County bought the Wisconsin and Virginia buildings.
- The Legion of Honor is an exact replica of the French Pavilion, built at Lands End with a gift from Alma and Adolph Spreckels, and it honors the soldiers killed in World War I while housing a museum.
- The Civic Auditorium, now the Bill Graham Civic Auditorium, was paid for in part with fair profits.
- The Marina Green and the yacht harbor descend from the fair's grounds and its passenger and freight slips. The harbor now has slips for more than 700 vessels.
The fair itself came out slightly ahead. Receipts were above $27 million and costs above $25 million, for a profit of about $1.3 million, and the last day set an attendance record of 450,000 people. Against that backdrop, the Palace's survival looks less like the result of a plan than of a stubborn public preference. When the staff and wood of everything else was hauled off, one building was saved because it was beautiful, and then saved again because it was loved.
The rebuild
The answer, reached in the early 1960s, was to build a copy. The state legislature provided $2 million for the project, Walter Johnson donated another $2 million, and Johnson and Caspar Weinberger led the drive to save the building. In 1964 the original was completely demolished. A new Palace went up on the same site, built this time of poured-in-place concrete, with steel I-beams for the dome. A plaque credits B.F. Modglin with the work of 1964 to 1967.
The new building recreated the form of the original. The rotunda stands 162 feet tall. It sits beside the lagoon, with the colonnades arranged as Maybeck drew them, and the whole composition occupies a site of 17 acres. The exhibition hall behind the colonnade was refitted over the following years, with interior work continuing into the early 1970s.
The Palace is a rare case of reconstruction treated as preservation. What survives is the design, the siting and the experience of the place, all of which Maybeck conceived. The concrete is new. The ruin that looks centuries old is in its second life, and sixty years old.
A theater and a museum inside
The rebuilt hall had a history of its own. In 1969 the Exploratorium, the hands-on science museum founded that year by the physicist Frank Oppenheimer, moved into the former exhibit hall and stayed until January 2013, when it closed to move to a new waterfront home on Pier 15 (The Exploratorium on the waterfront). For more than four decades children and adults learned about light, sound and perception in a building Maybeck had meant to be seen from across the lagoon.
The Palace of Fine Arts Theatre, with 966 seats, opened in 1970 and has hosted performances and events since. Between the museum and the theater the Palace was a working building and not a monument, and that use has been part of the argument for keeping it up.
Keeping it standing
A concrete reconstruction does not end the maintenance, least of all in a neighborhood where the ground is fill. The Marina District sits on land created for the 1915 fair, and the 1989 earthquake showed how that fill behaves in strong shaking (The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake). The Palace has been renovated for that reason. A project completed in early 2009 renovated the lagoons and walkways and carried out a seismic retrofit, and work on the dome, rotunda and colonnades was done by 2010.
The city's Planning Department, which handles preservation review and landmark designations, treats buildings like this one as part of the city's historic fabric (San Francisco Planning).
What it adds up to
A few numbers hold the story together.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Fair | Panama-Pacific International Exposition, 1915; closed December 4 |
| Visitors | More than 18 million |
| Architect | Bernard Maybeck |
| Original material | Wood frame covered with staff (plaster and fiber) |
| Demolished | 1964 |
| Rebuilt | Poured-in-place concrete; plaque credits B.F. Modglin for 1964 to 1967 |
| Funding | $2 million from the state legislature and $2 million from Walter Johnson |
| Rotunda height | 162 feet |
| Site | 17 acres |
| Exploratorium tenancy | 1969 to January 2013 |
| Theatre | Opened 1970, 966 seats |
| Seismic retrofit and lagoon renovation | Early 2009; dome and colonnade work by 2010 |
A copy that has outlasted the original
The building's arithmetic is odd. The original Palace stood from 1915 until it was demolished in 1964, a span of 49 years. The concrete replacement, whose main work ran from 1964 to 1967, has now stood for nearly 60 years and is closing in on a decade longer than the original. For a building designed to be temporary, that is a strong record.
Visiting
The Palace is in the Marina, at the foot of the Presidio, and the grounds around the lagoon are open to walkers, photographers and picnickers (Marina; Presidio). Muni's 30 Stockton serves the Marina, and from the Presidio side the 43 Masonic and 28 19th Avenue lines come close (How to ride Muni). A walk around the lagoon takes a few minutes, and the path goes on toward the Marina Green and the yacht harbor, which began as part of the same 1915 fairground, so a visitor can follow the fair's footprint on foot. The best view of the rotunda is from the far side of the water, where it doubles in the lagoon, and the colonnade is best seen from inside, where the curved row of columns frames the dome. For free ways to spend a day in this part of the city, see Free things to do in San Francisco.
One more way to read the building: the fair that put it up lasted less than a year, and its buildings came down soon after. The one piece that remained was kept by public affection, and when it fell apart it was rebuilt with public money and private gifts. The Palace of Fine Arts is a record, in stone-colored concrete, of a city deciding that one of its temporary things should be permanent.