Blog
The city's zero-waste program
How San Francisco's three-bin system, free compost pails, battery and medicine disposal, repair events and reuse programs fit together, and who runs each part.
Garbage day in San Francisco comes in threes. At most addresses, three trucks or three compartments serve three containers, and the household is expected to do the sorting at the kitchen counter. That habit is the visible part of what the city calls zero waste, a goal of sending as little as possible to landfill by recovering, composting, reusing and recycling instead. The program is divided among several agencies and one private contractor, and it reaches into corners most residents never think of as trash: dead batteries, expired prescriptions, a broken toaster, a restaurant's leftover produce. Here is who does what and where each service lives.
Three bins, one contractor
Curbside collection is run by Recology, a private company under contract to the city, not a city department (trash, recycling and compost: the three-bin system). The system uses three containers, sorted by color and sign: recycling, compost and landfill. Compost, the green bin, takes food scraps, food-soiled paper and yard trimmings. Recycling takes clean bottles, cans, paper and cardboard. What fits in neither goes to landfill.
The rules that trip up newcomers are mostly about timing and handling. Containers go to the curb the night before collection. Recology works every holiday except Christmas Day and New Year's Day, with one-day delays on the days that follow. Bulky items such as mattresses and old furniture do not get left on the sidewalk on a whim; they are arranged through Recology, set at the curb after 6 p.m. the day before and out by 6 a.m. on collection day. Recology's collection-day lookup and customer service line handle questions about a particular address.
The sorting rules shift, because the markets for recycled materials shift, so the city keeps a "Sort your items" tool on the Department of the Environment website. It answers the question the lid cannot: is a greasy pizza box compost, is a plastic clamshell recycling, where does a lightbulb go. The same site has a custom sign maker for building owners and businesses that want a clear sign for their own bins. A building that sorts well has a sign at the bin; a building that sorts badly usually does not (San Francisco Department of the Environment).
Who runs what
Three city bodies and one contractor touch waste, and a resident saves time by knowing which is which.
- The Department of the Environment sets policy and runs education. It publishes SF Recycles, a guide to reuse and recycling, and a general "All about Zero Waste" resource page. It runs the programs below that are not collection itself.
- San Francisco Public Works keeps the streets: street sweeping, graffiti, litter baskets and illegal dumping. A mattress dumped on a sidewalk or a pile of bags at a corner is a 311 report, and Public Works crews respond (San Francisco Public Works).
- Billing is separate. A bill for water and sewer comes from the Public Utilities Commission; a bill for garbage collection comes from Recology.
- Recology collects. Its work is governed by a contract and by the city's mandatory recycling and composting ordinance, which since 2009 has required residents and businesses to separate recycling and compost from trash.
The state sits above all of it. A state law, SB 1383, sets requirements for organic waste and food recovery, and the Department of the Environment lists the food-recovery requirements on its site. The law aims to keep food scraps and edible food out of landfills, where they produce methane, and to move surplus edible food to people who need it. For a restaurant, grocer or cafeteria, that means compost service and, for larger generators, food-recovery arrangements.
Compost, from the kitchen to the garden
Composting is the program's most distinctive piece. The Department of the Environment offers residents a free compost pail for the kitchen, a small countertop container that makes the habit easier, since the green bin is outside and the scraps are inside. The finished product comes back to the people who made it: the department says residents can also get high-quality compost for free. The idea is a closed loop, with scraps going out in the green bin and compost coming back to gardens and farms.
This matters for neighborhood gardens too. The city's community gardens and the sidewalk gardens managed through the Public Works permit system depend on soil that does not wash away in the rain, and free compost helps (urban agriculture and community gardens, trees and the urban forest). The same material supports the city's food-scraps system, covered in its own post (composting: how food scraps leave the kitchen).
Batteries, bulbs and other things that do not belong in any bin
Household batteries are among the few waste items that can start a fire in a truck or a sorting plant, because lithium cells can ignite when crushed. San Francisco gives household battery recycling its own page on the Department of the Environment site, and the rule is simple: batteries do not go in any of the three bins. They go to a drop-off. Rechargeable batteries in phones, laptops and tools, and the small button cells in watches and hearing aids, should be taped at the terminals if the instructions say to and taken to a drop-off listed on the department page.
Medicine gets the same treatment. A page on safe medicine disposal sets out three options for unwanted prescriptions and over-the-counter drugs. Flushing and tossing in the trash are discouraged because pills can reach water supplies and because medicines left in household trash are a risk to children and pets. The department's page lists the current drop-off options and locations, and it is the authority, since pharmacy and kiosk participation changes.
Paints, solvents, motor oil, pesticides and fluorescent tubes are hazardous household waste. They are collected under a separate program, not at the curb, and a resident needs to check the Department of the Environment page for the current process. For a chemical you cannot identify, do not pour it down a drain or into a bin.
Reuse and repair
The least visible part of the program is the part that keeps things out of the bin in the first place. The Department of the Environment promotes repair and reuse as the top of the waste hierarchy, above recycling:
- Repair information, events and clinics. The department posts repair resources and clinics where volunteers help fix small appliances, clothing and bikes.
- The SF Reusable Cup Challenge. A campaign to move coffee shops and customers toward reusable cups, a target that fits the city's long record of rules on single-use items. San Francisco was an early adopter of a plastic bag ban in 2007 and has since restricted foam foodware.
- SF Recycles. A directory for finding places that take furniture, building materials, electronics and clothing for reuse, so usable goods end up with someone who wants them.
For a household, the practical move is to ask three questions in order before reaching for a bin. Can it be repaired? Can someone else use it? If neither, which bin is it?
Businesses, buildings and the front of the house
The ordinance applies to everyone, and the details differ by customer. A single-family home gets one set of three containers. An apartment building shares them, and the property manager decides where the bins sit and how tenants learn what goes where; the Department of the Environment's sign maker is aimed at them. Restaurants and grocery stores produce a very different waste stream, heavy in food scraps and cardboard, so they are the main customers for compost collection and food-recovery arrangements under the state law. Offices and event venues face another problem: crowds, one-time visitors and sorting stations that people use for two seconds and never again.
Construction and demolition are a separate stream altogether. Building materials such as wood, drywall, concrete and metal make up a large share of the material the city could reuse, and the city's rules for building projects treat them separately from household waste. Anyone planning a remodel should ask the permit center and their contractor about debris requirements before work starts (Department of Building Inspection and the Permit Center).
Why the goal keeps moving
San Francisco set a goal of reaching zero waste, and it has repeatedly reported high diversion rates, meaning the share of material kept out of landfill. The goal is still a goal. Landfill tonnage continues, because some material still cannot be recycled or composted, because contamination spoils loads (a plastic bag in a compost bin can ruin a batch), and because building materials, bulky items and construction debris are a large share of what gets thrown out. The Department of the Environment describes the next steps in terms of product design, producer responsibility and reducing waste at the source, not just better sorting, since the cheapest ton of waste to manage is the one never made.
The department also runs energy and climate programs, which is why waste and energy live in the same city agency. In its own description, SF Environment has been at the forefront of local environmental work for some three decades, and it administers a large annual incentive program for building electrification. Waste is the program residents see most often, since it arrives at the curb every week.
Practical steps
- Get a free kitchen compost pail from the Department of the Environment if you do not have one.
- Look up an unfamiliar item with the "Sort your items" tool before guessing.
- Keep batteries, bulbs and medicines out of the three bins and use the drop-offs the department lists.
- Arrange bulky-item pickup through Recology and set items out after 6 p.m. the day before.
- Report dumping, overflowing public litter baskets and street trash through 311 (Using 311 in San Francisco, by phone, app or web).
- Ask a question about your own address's collection day or bin size to Recology's customer service line, 415-330-1300.
The deal the city offers is a modest amount of sorting at home in return for a system that turns a large share of what residents throw out back into soil, materials or reused goods. It runs on millions of small habits, and it succeeds or fails at the kitchen counter.