Blog
Trees and the urban forest
How a San Francisco block gets a street tree, who maintains it, how to report a fallen one and how a sidewalk garden permit works, step by step.
Walk down any residential block in the Richmond or the Sunset and the trees seem to have been there since before the streetcars. They were not. For most of the nineteenth century the western half of San Francisco was shifting sand dunes, and every bit of green you see now went in the ground one hole at a time, courtesy of park gardeners, private owners and city crews. The east side tells the same story with less room to work: the sidewalks are older, and a young tree has to squeeze in around cable vaults, driveways and bus stops. So the tree over your head is part of a public system with its own rules, its own paperwork and a long list of reasons why one particular square of sidewalk can or cannot hold a trunk.
Here is how that system works. It covers who plants the trees, who tends them, what happens when one comes down in a storm, and how a resident gets from bare concrete to a tree or a sidewalk garden.
Who plants, and who pays for the pruning
San Francisco Public Works plants street trees, together with its grant partner Friends of the Urban Forest, a nonprofit that has been organizing neighborhood planting days for decades. Inside Public Works, the Bureau of Urban Forestry runs the program. It keeps the inventory, approves the species, reviews each site and issues the permits (San Francisco Public Works).
What surprises plenty of longtime residents is who looks after a tree once it is in. The city does, from planting through maturity, and that includes fixing the sidewalk when the roots heave it. Property owners are not responsible for the tree in front of their building. It was not always so. Under the older arrangement the owner of the lot next to a tree was treated as its caretaker, until voters moved street-tree maintenance to the city in November 2016. The city's pages now put it plainly: the department prunes, waters young trees and handles the sidewalk.
Trees inside the parks are another matter. The Recreation and Park Department has the trees of Golden Gate Park, Lake Merced, Dolores Park and every other park and playground, and its gardeners work in a tradition that reaches back to the park's first superintendent (San Francisco Recreation and Park Department, Golden Gate Park's 1,017 acres). The rule of thumb runs like this. A tree on the sidewalk is Public Works. A tree behind a park fence is Rec and Park. A tree in a private yard belongs to the owner, although the city regulates removal of large and significant trees on private property. If you cannot tell which is which, call 311 and let them sort it out (Using 311 in San Francisco, by phone, app or web).
How a block gets its tree
The city does not sit around waiting for a resident to ask. Public Works and Friends of the Urban Forest pick out blocks with empty sidewalk squares and plan their plantings in batches. The work leaves marks on the pavement, and they are easy to read once you know the code:
- White paint, including the letters BUF and USA, marks a potential planting site. BUF is the Bureau of Urban Forestry. USA is Underground Service Alert, the call crews make before any digging so that gas, water, electric and telecom lines get marked.
- Green paint reading CUT and PLANT shows where the new tree basin, the square opening in the sidewalk, is meant to go.
Before anyone swings a shovel, each site is checked for utilities, driveways, curb ramps and other clearances. Sites fail for plain reasons: a gas service line in the wrong spot, a driveway apron too close, a hydrant, a bus stop, or a corner that has to stay open for sight lines. The new basins are cut bigger than the old one-square pits, running across two sidewalk squares, and they are filled level with the walk so that nobody with a stroller or a wheelchair trips over a lip of soil.
Public Works sends the adjacent owner a courtesy notice before it cuts a new basin. It does not need the owner's permission to plant, and no property-owner permit is required for a city planting. A tree on the public sidewalk stands on public land.
Picking the species
Residents cannot opt out, but they can weigh in on what goes in. Before the planting date, a resident can write to the Urban Forestry program at [email protected] and ask to choose from the species in the planting inventory. If nobody answers, a city arborist picks one that suits the site. The sensible choice turns on what is overhead (power lines favor small trees), how wide the sidewalk runs, and the microclimate. In the fog belt of the Outer Richmond and Outer Sunset, the downtown station's normal summer highs in the mid-60s say little about the cool, windy blocks near the ocean. A tree has a harder life there than on a sunny block in the Mission or Potrero Hill.
Objecting to a planting
A resident who does not want a tree can protest in writing. The letter should give the address, the reasons and a request for a hearing, and it goes by email to [email protected] or by mail to the Bureau of Urban Forestry. Two things matter here. A protest does not pause the planting. And if the protest is upheld after the tree is in, the city takes the tree out and repaves the sidewalk at no cost to the owner. The department also says what tends to fail: protests about falling leaves, lost parking, blocked views, car-door access or pet waste are generally not upheld, since the benefits of a tree to the block are weighed against ordinary inconveniences.
When a tree comes down
Storm winds and wet winters do most of the damage. The city's wet season runs roughly November to April, with December averaging about 4.8 inches of rain in the downtown normals, and a saturated root zone plus one strong gust is how most street trees go over (The wet season, November to April).
If a limb or a whole tree has fallen across a sidewalk or street, report it through 311 by phone, app or web. Public Works answers street and sidewalk reports, and the department's service standard is to address a concern within about 48 hours on weekdays. Hazards that block traffic or involve wires get triaged faster. If a tree has pulled down power lines, treat it as an emergency: stay back, keep others away and call 911. Leave the chainsaw alone. The city, not the owner, handles removal of a public tree, and the stump work rides along on the same service request.
A dead or dying tree that is still standing is also a 311 report. An arborist inspects, and if the tree is hazardous Public Works schedules the removal and, where the site allows, replants. Taking out a healthy street tree is a different animal. That takes a formal application, public notice and a hearing, which is why a resident cannot simply ask for a tree to go because it drops leaves.
Planting one yourself, or a garden strip
A resident who wants something the city has not scheduled has two routes, and the second is what most people mean by a sidewalk garden.
- Request a tree. Contact Public Works or Friends of the Urban Forest. Renters can ask as well as owners. Staff check the site against the clearance rules and, if it passes, put it on a planting day. On the day, a Friends of the Urban Forest staff member shows how to plant a tree and the neighbors do the planting alongside. Public Works lists no fee for a tree-planting permit.
- Apply for a sidewalk landscape permit. Planters, garden strips and groundcover in the sidewalk right-of-way need a Sidewalk Landscaping Permit from Public Works, which may be submitted with the street-tree request. Urban Forestry staff approve the plant species and the layout. The permit holder is responsible for upkeep, which is the opposite of the street-tree rule.
A few numbers shape both routes. A new tree may not leave less than 48 inches of unobstructed sidewalk width, the minimum the city treats as workable for walking and wheelchairs, and trees in the sidewalk must be pruned to keep 80 inches of clearance above the walking surface. Basin size depends on how wide the sidewalk is. The Urban Forestry permits line is 628-652-8733.
The 48-inch rule has a visible result. Narrow sidewalks on the older streets of Chinatown, the Tenderloin and parts of the Mission often cannot take a street tree at all, while the wide sidewalks of the Sunset can take larger species. Hence the leafy canopy on one block and a long line of bare squares on the next. It is also why the city hunts for other places to put greenery: corner bulbouts, widened sidewalks at transit stops, and the stormwater planters called rain gardens, which do the work of trees and landscaping at once (Rain Guardians and Adopt-a-Drain).
The long game
San Francisco has fewer trees per resident than many American cities, and the cause is history as much as policy. The older neighborhoods were built dense and early, pavement from edge to edge. The western neighborhoods were planted after the dunes were stabilized, partly out of the park's own nursery tradition and partly by private subdivisions that added street trees of their own in the 1920s through 1950s. That mixed past explains why the Outer Sunset's rows of Monterey cypress and eucalyptus look nothing like the flowering trees on an older block in the Inner Richmond (Inner Richmond, Outer Sunset).
The forest also does work that rarely makes the news. Canopy shades pavement and buildings, so a treed block is measurably cooler on a warm September afternoon, and September is the warmest month in the downtown normals, with an average high of 70.2 degrees. Leaves and roots slow stormwater in the wet season, which eases the load on the combined sewer system serving much of the city. Trees also filter some airborne particles, though they are no substitute for cleaner fuel and traffic policy.
So, for the resident with a bare square out front: look for the white and green paint. Write to Urban Forestry if you want a say in the species. Report a fallen tree through 311. If you want a garden strip, apply for the sidewalk landscape permit and expect to tend what you plant. And if the city does propose a tree on your block, take comfort that the roots, the sidewalk repairs and the pruning are Public Works' job for as long as it stands.