Blog
The Winter of Love, 2004
The same-sex marriage licenses San Francisco issued from February 12 to March 11, 2004, the rulings that halted them and the road to the 2008 marriage cases.
For four weeks in the winter of 2004, the rotunda of San Francisco City Hall was the most photographed wedding venue in the country. Couples, many of whom had waited decades, wound up the staircase and through the building in long lines, and clerks issued marriage licenses to same-sex couples in defiance of state law. The weeks became known as the Winter of Love. They ended with a court order, but the legal fight they started ran through the courts of California and the United States for nine years.
How it started
On February 10, 2004, the mayor wrote to the county clerk and asked that the city's marriage license form be changed so same-sex couples could apply. State law at the time defined marriage as between a man and a woman, so the request set the city against the statute, and the city's later legal position was that the California Constitution's guarantee of equal protection required the change. San Francisco is a city and county, so the same government that runs City Hall also issues the county's marriage licenses, and its clerk could act without waiting on anyone else (Why San Francisco is both a city and a county).
The first licenses were issued February 12. That morning the assessor-recorder married Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon in a small ceremony in her City Hall office. The two women, a couple for more than fifty years who had helped found one of the country's first lesbian organizations, the Daughters of Bilitis, were among the first to receive a license. Other couples followed through the day.
Four weeks at City Hall
Between February 12 and March 11, San Francisco issued more than 4,000 marriage licenses to same-sex couples. Different accounts give totals that range from over 3,400 to over 4,000, depending on how the licenses and the ceremonies are counted. City Hall stayed open through the Valentine's Day weekend to keep marrying couples, and the building's staff worked long days to keep up.
The scene was part celebration and part protest. Couples came from across California and from other states, and many had been together for decades. The ceremonies took place in the rotunda, on the staircase and in offices throughout the building (San Francisco City Hall, the building). The images of those weeks, couples with licenses in their hands, shaped how the public saw the question.
The courts step in
The legal response began within days. On February 17, a San Francisco Superior Court judge declined to issue an immediate restraining order, and the marriages continued. On February 19, the City Attorney's office filed a cross-complaint against the State of California, the first time a government had challenged anti-gay marriage laws in the United States.
On March 11, 2004, the California Supreme Court ordered the city to stop issuing the licenses. Within hours the City Attorney filed a separate complaint against the State in superior court so the question of whether the marriage laws were constitutional could be heard. On August 12, 2004, the California Supreme Court ruled that the mayor had lacked authority to order the clerk to issue the licenses, and it invalidated the marriages performed in February and March. The ruling was about the mayor's power, not about whether the marriage statutes were constitutional; that question was left for the lawsuit the city had filed.
For the thousands of couples who had married that winter, the ruling meant the licenses in their hands had no legal force. Many felt it as a loss, and the city's later accounts of the event note the tension: the celebration was real, and so was the reversal.
Four years of litigation
The city's lawsuit moved through three levels of California courts.
| Date | Step |
|---|---|
| March 2005 | A superior court judge rules that the state's marriage laws violate the equal protection clause of the state constitution |
| October 10, 2006 | A divided Court of Appeal upholds the laws; one justice dissents |
| December 20, 2006 | The California Supreme Court agrees to review the case, known as In re Marriage Cases |
| March 4, 2008 | Oral argument |
| May 15, 2008 | The court holds that excluding same-sex couples violates the state constitution's guarantees of privacy, liberty and equal protection |
| June 16 and 17, 2008 | The decision becomes final and same-sex weddings resume |
The 2008 decision was the result supporters of the Winter of Love had been seeking. Weddings resumed in San Francisco and elsewhere in California in the summer of 2008. In September 2008 the mayor who had issued the 2004 licenses officiated at the wedding of two women who had been plaintiffs in the marriage cases.
Proposition 8 and the federal courts
The victory did not last. On June 3, 2008, a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage, Proposition 8, qualified for the November ballot, and on November 4, 2008, it passed with 52 percent of the vote. The next day San Francisco, together with Los Angeles and Santa Clara counties, filed an original proceeding in the California Supreme Court challenging the measure as an improper constitutional revision, and other local governments joined. On May 26, 2009, the court upheld Proposition 8 as a valid amendment.
The fight moved to federal court. A case called Perry v. Schwarzenegger was filed in federal court in San Francisco in 2009, and the city moved to intervene on the plaintiffs' side, which the court allowed. A trial took place in January 2010. In August 2010 the federal district court ruled that Proposition 8 violated the Fourteenth Amendment. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, which sits in San Francisco, affirmed the ruling in February 2012, and the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to review the case in December 2012.
On June 26, 2013, in Hollingsworth v. Perry, the Supreme Court held that the proponents of Proposition 8 lacked standing to appeal, and the lower-court ruling stood. That restored marriage equality across California. In 2015 same-sex marriage became legal in all 50 states.
The City Attorney's office has said it was the only legal team that was a party in every aspect of the California litigation, in every case, court and judge, from early 2004 through June 2013 (What the City Attorney does for the city; City Attorney).
Two questions, kept apart
The Winter of Love raised two distinct legal questions, and the courts answered them separately, which is why the story is easy to get wrong in the retelling.
- Could the mayor and clerk issue the licenses on their own authority? This was a question about the powers of local officials. The California Supreme Court answered it March 11, 2004, with the order to stop, and August 12, 2004, with the ruling that the mayor had lacked authority. The answer was no.
- Do the state's marriage laws violate the state constitution? This was a question about the constitution. The City Attorney's office brought it through a separate lawsuit, and it did not wait for the first question to be decided. A superior court judge answered yes in March 2005, a divided appeals court answered no in October 2006, and the California Supreme Court answered yes on May 15, 2008.
That distinction explains how a set of marriages could be voided in 2004 and the underlying claim vindicated in 2008. The licenses of 2004 were invalid because of how they had been issued. The constitutional claim was a different matter, decided by a different process, with briefs, a record and oral argument.
Where the work happens in City Hall
The licenses of 2004 were issued, as they are today, by the Office of the County Clerk, which sits in City Hall and answers to the City Administrator (The county side of City Hall). The County Clerk issues marriage licenses and performs civil ceremonies at City Hall, and its public number is 415-554-4950. That function exists in this form only because San Francisco is both a city and a county: elsewhere in California the county clerk belongs to a county government separate from any city's. In San Francisco the clerk's office is part of the same government as the mayor's, which is one reason the mayor was in a position to act.
Remembering it
San Francisco marked the 20th anniversary of the Winter of Love on February 14, 2024, with a celebration at City Hall, where nearly 200 couples were registered to marry that day. The city has also noted how routine the ceremony has become: in 2023 more than 9,000 public marriages were recorded with the city, up from about 3,800 in 2020, when the pandemic had shut down much of the ceremony schedule. In the spring of 2024 a pilot appointment service was to offer same-day copies of marriage certificates to a fixed number of couples each day.
The significance of the winter is partly that of a moment and partly that of a method. A local government used its administrative power to test a constitutional question and then took the question through every level of court. Supporters see an example of civil disobedience carried out by an elected official, one that eventually produced a legal result. Critics at the time argued that a mayor and a clerk were not entitled to decide for themselves which state laws to follow, and the August 2004 ruling on the mayor's authority reflects the same point. Both observations are part of the record.
Marrying at City Hall today
The County Clerk's office in City Hall still issues licenses. California requires that a license be used within 90 days of issuance, and applicants must be two unmarried people at least 18 with valid identification. California residency and citizenship are not required. A civil ceremony at City Hall for six guests or fewer is booked by appointment through the County Clerk. The step-by-step guide to the process is in Getting married at City Hall.
The City Hall rotunda, where so many of the 2004 ceremonies took place, is a short walk from the Civic Center's other landmarks (Civic Center). The Castro neighborhood, where the city's gay community has had a center for decades, is described in Castro.