Blog
The overpaid executive gross receipts tax
How San Francisco's pay-ratio tax works, who is exempt, what Proposition M changed in 2024 and the arguments voters and businesses make about it.
Most business taxes want to know how much a company sells or how much floor it leases. San Francisco's overpaid executive gross receipts tax wants to know something else: how far apart are the best-paid manager and the typical worker? If the highest-paid managerial employee earns more than 100 times the median pay of the company's San Francisco employees, the company owes an extra tax on its San Francisco gross receipts, and the rate climbs with the size of the ratio. By the standards of the city budget it is a small tax, a modest rate on a large base, but it is one of the plainest cases in town of a ballot measure trying to steer behavior through the tax code as well as raise money. What follows is a case study of how it works and how the argument over it runs, stated neutrally.
How the tax works
The mechanism has three parts, according to the Treasurer and Tax Collector's description for tax years 2025 and later.
The trigger. The tax applies when a business's highest-paid managerial employee, wherever based, earns more than 100 times the median compensation of employees based in San Francisco for the tax year. The highest-paid employee's compensation is left out of the median calculation, so one enormous pay package cannot drag the median upward.
The base. The tax is generally measured by the business's gross receipts from taxable activities attributable to San Francisco. It is not a tax on the executive's pay, and it is not a tax on the amount by which the pay exceeds the threshold. It is a small percentage of the company's local receipts, owed because the ratio crosses a line.
The rate. The rate rises with the pay ratio. For tax years 2025 and 2026, the schedule runs as follows:
| Pay ratio | Rate |
|---|---|
| Above 100:1 to 200:1 | 0.020% |
| Above 200:1 to 300:1 | 0.040% |
| Above 300:1 to 400:1 | 0.060% |
| Above 400:1 to 500:1 | 0.080% |
| Above 500:1 to 600:1 | 0.100% |
| Above 600:1 | 0.120% |
The rates creep up in later years: for 2027 the first tier is 0.021 percent and the top tier is 0.125 percent, and for 2028 the top tier is 0.129 percent. Businesses subject to the administrative office tax pay a higher schedule, starting at 0.080 percent for the 100:1 to 200:1 tier and reaching 0.480 percent above 600:1 for 2025 and 2026.
A worked example
Take a hypothetical company that is not exempt and has $50,000,000 in taxable San Francisco gross receipts. Say the median compensation of its San Francisco employees is $100,000 and its highest-paid managerial employee earns $25,000,000, a ratio of 250 to 1. That lands in the 200:1 to 300:1 tier, so the rate for 2025 and 2026 is 0.040 percent, and the tax is $50,000,000 multiplied by 0.0004, which is $20,000.
If the company trimmed the top salary to $9,000,000, the ratio would drop to 90 to 1, under the 100:1 threshold, and the tax would be zero. If the same company's top pay package climbed to $70,000,000, the ratio would be 700 to 1 and the rate 0.120 percent, making the tax $60,000. The example shows the structure: modest in dollars, with a sharp cliff at 100 to 1 and a ladder above it. It is a hypothetical, and each company's actual figures depend on how the Treasurer defines compensation and the managerial employee.
Who is exempt
Plenty of businesses never meet this tax. For tax year 2025, the Treasurer's guidance says a business must file if it was engaged in business in San Francisco, was not otherwise exempt, and had more than $5,000,000 in combined taxable San Francisco gross receipts. Businesses exempt from the gross receipts tax as small business enterprises are generally exempt from this one too, except those subject to the administrative office tax. A business is also exempt if it has 1,000 or fewer U.S. employees and $1 billion or less in gross receipts on its federal income tax returns. Residential landlords with $5,000,000 or less in gross receipts in the current or prior tax year are generally exempt from estimated payments.
In practice that confines the tax to large employers with a big national footprint. Proposition M, approved in November 2024, wrote the 1,000-employee and $1 billion exemption into the tax, along with other changes, and those exemptions are why the budget describes the revenue effect of the measure as a reduction.
History: from 2020 to Proposition M
Voters approved the tax in November 2020, and it took effect in 2022. Supporters of a pay-ratio tax argue that it gives companies a reason to narrow the gap between top and typical pay and raises money for city services in the meantime.
Proposition M, approved in November 2024, changed the exemptions, the way executive pay is calculated and the rates. The mayor's budget book describes the result as cutting the overpaid executive tax by 80 percent while generally raising gross receipts tax rates, as part of a restructuring of the business tax code. The Treasurer's tables for tax years 2025 and 2026 show the lowered rates above. The Treasurer's page also notes that estimated payments for this tax are due April 30, July 31 and October 31, and that the tax is filed with the annual business registration and tax form.
The arguments
The debate over the tax shows two coherent positions that start from different premises.
Supporters make four arguments. The first is fairness: when one manager earns hundreds of times what typical workers earn, the company can afford to pay its local workers more, and the tax prompts the question. The second is revenue: even modest rates produce money for a city that has repeatedly faced budget shortfalls. The third is signaling: a ratio calculated and published every year puts pay gaps on the record. The fourth is that the tax falls on the largest companies and spares small businesses, which is true in light of the exemptions.
Critics make four of their own. The first is that a pay-ratio tax is an indirect tool: it taxes receipts, not pay, so companies with thin margins and large receipts bear more tax than companies with high margins and small payrolls. The second is that the ratio can be moved by hiring practices instead of pay, since a company that outsources lower-paid work to contractors can raise its median pay without raising anyone's wages. The third is that the tax is another layer in a tax code that already has several, and that complexity is itself a cost. The fourth is that it applies to companies with employees all over the country while counting only San Francisco workers in the median, which they say can distort the comparison.
The city's budget book treats the tax as a modest revenue item, and the Controller reports on the efficacy of the Proposition M changes. A neutral reading is that the tax's effect on pay is hard to measure and its effect on revenue is small next to the gross receipts tax and the homelessness tax around it.
How a company files
A company subject to the tax reports it on the Annual Business Registration and Tax Form, the same filing that carries the gross receipts tax and the registration fee. The compliance step is mostly a matter of working out two numbers each year: the highest-paid managerial employee's compensation, and the median compensation of the employees based in San Francisco, excluding that top employee. The ratio sets the tier. Estimated payments are due April 30, July 31 and October 31, so a company that expects to cross a threshold pays during the year and not in one lump after the fact.
In any pay-ratio tax the definitions carry the weight: who counts as an employee based in San Francisco, how remote workers are treated, what compensation includes. Proposition M changed the calculation of the highest-paid executive's pay, which is part of the reason the Treasurer's pages for tax years 2025 and later are separate from the pages for earlier years. A company trying to understand its position reads the current definitions and does not assume the 2022 rules still apply.
What the numbers say about its size
The city's budget does not break out the overpaid executive tax by itself. Business tax revenue as a whole, which the budget says is comprised of business registration fees, the administrative office tax, the gross receipts tax and the overpaid executive tax, is budgeted at $1,572.2 million in the General Fund for 2026-27. The budget notes that Proposition M reduced the overpaid executive tax by 80 percent, so whatever share this component held before, it is smaller now. A tax that raises relatively little and reaches few companies still draws attention because it states a principle.
That is the pattern with this tax. It is better understood as a statement about pay ratios, enacted by ballot, than as a pillar of the budget, and its rates were cut in 2024 as part of a measure that reorganized most other business taxes and more than doubled the small business exemption.
Where the Treasurer comes in
The Treasurer and Tax Collector administers the tax as part of the annual business tax return, and the office's pages carry the current rate tables, the definitions and the forms. Office of the Treasurer and Tax Collector describes the office. The gross receipts tax and the other San Francisco business taxes places this tax among the other business taxes, and What San Franciscans pay in taxes shows where business taxes fit in the larger picture. The official rate tables are at sftreasurer.org.
This is general information, not tax advice. How a particular company's ratio is computed is a matter for the Treasurer's rules.