Blog
Robotaxis on San Francisco streets
Who regulates driverless cars in San Francisco, how to report a problem to 311, and what supporters and critics argue, drawn from city and state records.
For a lot of Americans, the first empty driver's seat they ever saw at a red light was in San Francisco. Driverless cars have been part of the traffic here for years, and they have kicked off one of the longest-running quarrels over what a city may decide about its own streets. The short version is that the city decides less than people assume. What follows is a plain account of that dispute: who holds the authority, how a resident can report a problem and what each side argues.
Who is in charge
Start with the surprise. San Francisco does not issue the permits. The San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency says on its autonomous vehicle page that the State of California has sole authority to regulate autonomous vehicles, and it adds that the city "cannot revoke or limit those permits." Two state agencies hold the authority:
- The Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) regulates testing and deployment of autonomous vehicles on public roads. A company needs a DMV permit to operate driverless cars at all.
- The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) regulates passenger service in autonomous vehicles. A company can obtain a CPUC permit to carry paying riders only after it has the underlying DMV permit.
The state decides whether companies can operate in San Francisco, how many vehicles they run and where they serve. The SFMTA does not issue permits for autonomous vehicle testing or operation. What the city has are the levers it controls itself: its streets, its transit system, its emergency responders and its voice in state proceedings (see San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency).
That structure explains the shape of the argument. City officials answer to residents for how the streets work, but they do not hold the key decision. The state holds it, and the state regulates the whole of California at once.
A short timeline
- Before 2023: Companies test autonomous vehicles in the city under DMV permits, first with safety drivers and later without them.
- 2023: The SFMTA files a protest with the CPUC against a request by Waymo to expand its service. It argues that the request was unreasonable because it lacked incrementalism, data transparency, enough driverless testing and adequate reporting and monitoring. On August 10, 2023, the CPUC votes to allow two companies, Waymo and Cruise, to expand paid driverless service in San Francisco on a round-the-clock basis.
- October 2023: After a Cruise vehicle was involved in a serious incident in which a pedestrian was injured, the DMV suspends Cruise's driverless permits on October 24, 2023.
- Late 2024: The company that owned Cruise stops funding its robotaxi work, ending that service.
- 2025 and after: Waymo continues to operate in the city, and the SFMTA continues to make filings about emergencies and incidents, drawing on calls to 311 and 911 and on reports from fire department leadership and transit operators.
The two 2023 dates belong side by side. In August, the state's utility regulator widened what the companies could do, over the city's objection. Within weeks, a serious incident led another state agency to pull one company's right to run driverless cars at all. Each camp can point to one of those events. Supporters can say the regulatory system corrected itself. Critics can say the correction came only after someone was hurt.
What supporters argue
People who favor autonomous vehicles in the city make several arguments, and they deserve a fair hearing.
- Safety potential. Serious crashes often involve human error. Supporters argue that a system that does not drink, text or tire can reduce injuries, and they point to the companies' own data as evidence.
- Access. For people who cannot drive, including some people with disabilities and some older adults, a driverless ride can offer independence.
- Coverage. A robotaxi can serve places and hours where transit and taxis are thin.
- The first years of a technology. Proponents say early mistakes are the price of learning, and that regulating too soon would keep the technology from improving.
What critics argue
Critics, among them some city officials, transit advocates and labor groups, make their own case.
- Emergency response. First responders have reported cases in which driverless vehicles blocked or delayed fire trucks, ambulances or police. The city's filings highlight incident reports from fire leadership and transit operators.
- Transit and traffic. Stalled or confused vehicles can block Muni lines and intersections. A transit system carrying many riders can be held up by a single stopped car.
- Data and oversight. The city has asked for more data and more reporting. In its 2023 protest, the SFMTA said the CPUC request did not include adequate data transparency or monitoring.
- Local control. Many residents feel that the people who live with the streets should have more say than they get under the state's authority.
- Jobs. Some drivers and unions argue that driverless service threatens livelihoods in the taxi and ride-hail industries.
Neither list is complete. One person can hold views from both columns, welcoming the access benefits, say, while wanting more local control.
How to report a problem
The city has a path for residents who run into trouble, and it is clear about who handles what.
- If something is happening now: if an incident is in progress or needs an emergency response, call 911.
- For a street experience with an autonomous vehicle in San Francisco: call 311, or fill out the city's online form, "Report autonomous vehicle incidents and complaints," on sf.gov. Including the company's name, such as Waymo or Zoox, helps. After you submit a report, you receive a tracking number from 311 (see Using 311 in San Francisco, by phone, app or web and SF311 Customer Service Center).
- For general policy questions: email [email protected].
- For feedback on testing and deployment: the DMV accepts feedback at [email protected] and through an online form.
- For feedback on the passenger service itself: the CPUC takes operational feedback at [email protected].
The division follows the authority. Since the city cannot revoke or limit permits, a city report becomes part of the record the city can present to the state. A report to the DMV or the CPUC goes straight to the agency that can act.
Why a state permit outranks a city rule
The city's hands are tied by a general feature of California law: some subjects are reserved to the state, and cities may not adopt rules that conflict with them. Vehicle regulation is one. A city sets the rules for its own property and operations, such as its parking meters, its transit lines and its curb space, but a rule about who may drive a car on a public road, or what a car must be able to do, is a state matter.
The distinction turns up in a lot of Bay Area disputes, ride-hail and scooters among them. Cities keep discovering that the lever that looks closest is not theirs to pull. In the autonomous vehicle case, the city's real options are persuasion and process: a formal protest in a state proceeding, a request for data, a public hearing and the daily record of 311 and 911 calls that the SFMTA can compile and file.
A checklist for a useful report
A report is only as good as its details. If you file one, these items help most:
- The place and the time. A cross street, a block and the approximate time let staff match the report to other records.
- The company. The city's form asks for the name, and the form's own example is Waymo or Zoox. A vehicle usually shows its operator on its body.
- What happened, in sequence. Describe the vehicle's behavior and the response around it: stopped, blocked a lane, did not yield, interfered with a bus or an emergency vehicle.
- Who else was affected. A bus held up, a pedestrian in a crosswalk or a delayed fire truck is the kind of fact the city's filings emphasize.
- Photos or video, if you took them safely. Do not stop in traffic to make them.
Reports about problems in progress, or ones involving injuries, belong at 911 first. Afterward, a 311 report or a state-agency email puts the event on the record.
Where robotaxis meet the rest of the transportation system
Several parts of the city's system touch autonomous vehicles.
- The airport. The airport lists autonomous rides alongside Lyft and Uber rides and taxis as separate pickup options on its ground-transportation pages (see Getting from SFO to the city).
- Taxis and ride-hail. The same 311 system takes reports about unpermitted taxis, and the city's broader taxi and ride-hail framework is separate from the state's autonomous vehicle permits.
- Bikes and pedestrians. How driverless cars deal with people on foot and on bikes is among the main safety questions, and it connects to the city's Vision Zero goals (see Baywheels, now Lyft Bike, and the bike-share system).
- The curb. Pickup and drop-off by driverless vehicles use the same curb space other vehicles use, which makes the curb rules relevant (see reading parking signs, street cleaning and color curbs).
What the record shows
A few conclusions are safe from the public record.
- The authority over driverless permits is the state's, not the city's.
- The city has used the tools it has: protests at the CPUC, incident reporting and public comment.
- The state has both expanded and restricted driverless service, and the same company that was expanded in 2023 was suspended in the same year.
- Reports from residents, through 311 and the state agencies, feed into that record.
The record does not settle the bigger question of whether the technology makes streets safer overall. That depends on data that the companies, regulators and independent researchers are still arguing over. Residents who want to follow it can read the SFMTA's autonomous vehicle page, the DMV's and CPUC's pages and the filings in the CPUC's proceedings.
A practical note for residents
If you live or walk where driverless service runs, a few habits help. Treat a driverless car like any other car at a crosswalk, make eye contact with the traffic around you rather than with a driver who is not there, and report a problem when you see one. For an emergency, call 911. For a street problem, call 311. The DMV and the CPUC decide the rules, but the first agency to hear about trouble on the street is the city's.