Blog
Just-cause eviction: what the San Francisco ordinance protects
What just cause means in San Francisco, the reasons a landlord may use, which tenants are covered and where the Rent Board's counselors can answer questions.
In San Francisco, "just cause" gets tossed around in kitchens and at Board of Supervisors hearings as shorthand for the whole apparatus of tenant protection. It is narrower than that, and more precise. Just cause is the rule that a landlord may end a tenancy only for a reason the Rent Ordinance names. What follows, in question-and-answer form, covers what the rule reaches, which tenants hold it, what the list of reasons looks like and where a tenant or landlord can get a straight answer. It is general information about a published ordinance, not legal advice. An eviction notice is a legal document, and the Rent Board's counselors and licensed advisers are the ones to ask about it.
What does "just cause" mean?
A landlord must have one of the reasons the Rent Ordinance lists in order to evict a tenant. The Rent Board puts it that way: a landlord must have just cause to evict. A lease running out is not a reason. Neither is wanting a higher rent from a new tenant, or being annoyed by a complaint. The Ordinance names the reasons, and a notice that does not state one has a problem on its face.
This is a separate thing from rent control. Rent control limits how much rent can rise each year. Just cause limits why a tenancy can end. The two protections cover different groups of units, and a unit can have one without the other. Rent control in San Francisco: myths and the 1979 cutoff explains the dividing lines.
Which tenants have it?
The Rent Board's guide says many units built on or before June 13, 1979 have both rent control and eviction protection, as long as the unit is not used as a single-family dwelling. The eviction-protection-only group includes units built after that date, most single-family homes and condominiums when the tenant moved in on or after January 1, 1996, units that have undergone substantial rehabilitation and units controlled or regulated by another government agency. So for many tenants in newer buildings, the Ordinance does not cap the rent, but the landlord still needs a just cause to end the tenancy.
A set of residential categories sits entirely outside the Ordinance, such as certain hotel and rooming house units occupied for fewer than 32 continuous days, units in resident-controlled non-profit cooperatives, certain care facilities and school dormitories. The Rent Board's list also names commercial space with incidental, infrequent residential use. Most ordinary apartment tenants are in none of those groups.
What are the reasons a landlord may use?
The Rent Board's page lists examples of just cause, and they fall into two broad families: reasons tied to what a tenant has done, and reasons tied to what the owner wants to do with the unit.
Reasons tied to the tenant's conduct:
- Nonpayment of rent, or frequent late payment.
- Breaking the terms of the rental agreement, or using the unit for an illegal purpose.
- Interfering with other people's comfort, safety or enjoyment of the building.
Reasons tied to the owner's plans:
- The landlord or an immediate family member plans to move into the unit.
- The landlord plans to convert the unit to a condominium and sell it.
- The landlord plans substantial work that makes the unit unlivable during construction. The tenant must be allowed to move back in immediately after the work is done.
- The landlord plans to remove all units in the building from the rental market under the Ellis Act, a state law that lets owners leave the rental business.
The Rent Board describes its list as examples. The full text is the Ordinance itself, in the part of the city's Administrative Code that governs rent control, and it attaches conditions to each reason. A landlord who wants to move in a relative, for instance, has to meet the Ordinance's conditions about who qualifies and how the unit is used afterward. A tenant served with a notice citing one of these reasons can ask a counselor to hold the facts up against the conditions.
What difference does the family make?
It changes what the tenant can expect. When the reason is the tenant's conduct, the question is whether the facts are true. A tenant accused of nonpayment can check the ledger, and one accused of a lease violation can ask what term was broken and whether the landlord offered a chance to fix it. When the reason is the owner's plans, the question is whether the plan is real and meets the Ordinance's conditions. These are sometimes called no-fault reasons, because the tenant has done nothing wrong, and the Ordinance attaches added protections to them, including payments to help the tenant relocate in some cases. The Rent Board publishes the current relocation figures, which change over time, so the board's pages are the place to look.
The Ellis Act reason shows how state and local law meet. State law gives an owner the right to go out of the rental business, and the city's Ordinance regulates how that process must treat tenants in San Francisco. Only a counselor or a lawyer can say how the two apply to a particular building, and the Rent Board's counselors can describe the process in general terms.
A hypothetical walk through the categories
Take three hypothetical notices. In each case the facts are invented.
In the first, a landlord serves a notice citing nonpayment of rent. The tenant pulls out the ledger and finds the March payment was made by check on March 3 and cashed on March 5. A conduct-based reason depends on facts, and the facts here may not support it. The tenant's first move is to document the payment and bring the record to a counselor.
In the second, a landlord serves a notice saying a relative will move into the unit. That is an owner-plan reason. The tenant would set the notice against the Ordinance's conditions on who qualifies, how the unit will be used and what must happen afterward, and could ask whether the unit the relative will occupy is in fact the one being vacated. The Rent Board's counselors can walk through the conditions.
In the third, a landlord serves a notice saying major renovation makes the unit unlivable during the work. The Rent Board's own summary says the tenant must be allowed to move back in immediately after the work is done. A tenant who gets such a notice should ask what the work is, how long it will take and what the plan is for the return.
The three cases show why the Ordinance names reasons: each one comes with facts that can be checked, and a notice that cites one has to be able to support it. They also show where a general explanation runs out. Whether a particular notice is valid depends on the building, the unit and the history, and those details belong with a counselor or a lawyer.
The tenant's side of the record
A few simple habits help anyone facing a notice. Keep every document, including the lease, notices, receipts and text messages. Note the dates a notice was delivered and how. Keep records of any repair requests, because they can explain a dispute over conduct. Do not ignore a court summons. The Rent Board's pages describe the services available and the forms for petitions, and the city's 311 line can route a general question to the right office. A tenant whose first language is not English can ask 311, which operates in over 160 languages, to connect an interpreter.
Landlords need much the same habits: keep the unit's classification, the lease, the notices served and the dates, and report to the Housing Inventory each year, since a rent increase given without a license can be void.
What happens if a landlord ignores the rules?
The Rent Board describes its work as including investigating wrongful evictions. It conducts arbitrations and mediations and handles tenant petitions, which include unlawful rent increase claims, rent history reviews and reductions for decreased housing services. A tenant who believes a notice does not state a valid reason can bring the question to the Board's counselors, whose phone line is 415-252-4600, open from 9 a.m. to noon and 1 p.m. to 4 p.m. on weekdays. The office is at 25 Van Ness Avenue, Suite 700.
An eviction that turns into a lawsuit is heard in the Superior Court, a state court that sits in the city, and a tenant who receives court papers has deadlines that run from the date of service. The Rent Board is not a court, and the court's rules, not the Board's, govern the lawsuit. That is why a tenant who receives anything with the word "summons" on it should seek legal help quickly. The city's counseling is a starting point, not a substitute. Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco describes the Superior Court as a state body that sits in the city.
How do the owner's reporting duties fit in?
Since the Housing Inventory began, owners must report their residential units to the Rent Board each year, and the system produces rent increase licenses for tenant-occupied units. Some rent increases given without a license can be void. The licensing system does not itself define just cause, but it gives the Board better records of who lives where and what they pay, which helps in reviewing both rent increases and the circumstances around tenancies. The Rent Board's housing inventory and fee portal describes the system.
Where to start
A tenant should:
- Keep the notice, the lease and any rent payment records in one place.
- Identify the reason the notice cites and compare it to the list above.
- Look up the building's classification on the Planning Department's Property Information Map, and note when the tenancy began.
- Call the Rent Board counselors with those facts.
A landlord should do the same in reverse: identify the reason, confirm the unit's category and read the Ordinance's conditions before serving a notice.
The city's overview is at sf.gov, and the office behind it is described in Rent Board and housing agencies. Renters' rights and rent control in San Francisco and How to use the Rent Board give the plain-language versions. Ordinance, ballot measure and state law all change the rules, and the Rent Board's current pages control.