Blog

Harvey Milk and George Moscone, 1977 to 1978

Milk's 1977 election to the Board of Supervisors, the ordinance and the Briggs fight, the November 27, 1978 killings at City Hall and the aftermath.

It was a Monday morning, the Monday after Thanksgiving, and the building under the gold dome was doing ordinary business when a former member of the Board of Supervisors walked in and shot two men. The date was November 27, 1978. The dead were the mayor, George Moscone, and the supervisor who represented the Castro, Harvey Milk, who was 48. The two had known each other as political allies, and the killings came at the end of a bitter year in the city's politics. They also came at the end of eleven months in which Milk had made himself the best-known openly gay elected official in the country.

A man who came to San Francisco in 1972

Harvey Milk was born in Woodmere, New York, in 1930. He served in the U.S. Navy from 1951 to 1955 and afterward worked as a teacher and as a researcher on Wall Street. In 1972 he moved to San Francisco and opened a camera store in the Castro District, then a neighborhood of working-class families that was filling with gay men moving in from other parts of the country. The shop became a gathering place, and Milk, a talker and organizer by temperament, became a local figure among the merchants and residents of the Castro (Castro Street and Eureka Valley).

He ran for office repeatedly and lost: several campaigns for the Board of Supervisors, and a bid for the state Assembly. The losses built his name. Each campaign brought more people into his orbit and more experience in the city's neighborhood politics. In 1977 the city elected its supervisors by district, which suited a candidate who was well known in one neighborhood, and Milk won the seat for the district that included the Castro.

Election and the Board

With his election in November 1977, Milk became the first openly gay man elected to public office in California. He took his seat in January 1978. The Board then had eleven members, as it does now, and Mayor George Moscone, who had been elected in 1975, was a political ally on many questions (Board of Supervisors).

Milk served for only eleven months, but his record in office was substantial. He sponsored a civil rights ordinance banning discrimination based on sexual orientation, which passed the Board 11 to 1. The one vote against it came from Supervisor Dan White. Moscone signed the ordinance in 1978.

Milk presented himself as a neighborhood supervisor as well as a symbol, and he kept his base in the shops and streets of the Castro. In a famous 1977 speech, "You've Got to Give 'em Hope," he spoke to young people who felt isolated; hand-edited drafts of the speech are among the papers held by the San Francisco Public Library's LGBTQIA center at the Main Library (The Main Library at Civic Center).

The Briggs Initiative

The largest fight of 1978 was not at City Hall. It was a statewide ballot measure known as the Briggs Initiative, which would have required California schools to fire gay teachers and anyone who supported them. Milk campaigned against it across the state, debating its sponsor and speaking in cities and small towns. On election day in November 1978 voters rejected the measure.

The defeat of the Briggs Initiative came three weeks before the killings. For supporters of gay rights it was a moment of vindication, and Milk, who had taken a leading role in the campaign, was at the height of his visibility.

Dan White

Dan White was a supervisor from another district, a former police officer and firefighter who had been elected in 1977 at the same time as Milk. On November 10, 1978, he resigned from the Board, saying that his supervisor's salary could not support his family. A few days later he asked Moscone to reappoint him. The mayor first appeared willing and then decided against it. He was to announce White's replacement on the morning of November 27.

That morning White went to City Hall, entered the building, and went to the mayor's office, where he shot Moscone. He then walked down the hall and shot Milk in his office. The killings took place within minutes of each other.

Why the Board's rules mattered

Two features of how the city governs itself explain the sequence of events in 1977 and 1978.

The first is the district system. San Francisco elected its supervisors citywide for most of the twentieth century, a system that favored candidates who could raise money and win votes across the whole city. In 1977 the voters chose supervisors by district, and the effect was immediate: a candidate such as Milk, who was widely known in one neighborhood and had little money, could win a seat. The Board returned to citywide elections in 1980 and went back to districts in 2000, and today it has eleven district supervisors, each elected by the residents of one district. In June 2026 voters approved lifetime term limits for the mayor and the supervisors, an additional change to the rules that shape who serves.

The second is the mayor's power to fill vacancies. When a supervisor resigns mid-term, the mayor appoints a replacement. That is why White, after resigning on November 10, asked Moscone to put him back, and why the mayor's decision on who would hold the seat was the day's main business on November 27. The appointment power gives a mayor real influence over the Board, a feature of the strong-mayor charter that has remained in place.

A note on how the story is told

Accounts of November 27 are often compressed to a single image: the shots, the vigil, the riot. The sequence is more useful held in order. A candidate wins a district seat in 1977. A rival supervisor from another part of town votes against the first ordinance and later resigns. A statewide campaign against gay teachers is defeated. A resignation is followed by a request to be reappointed, and the request is turned down. Within three weeks of the Briggs vote, two men are dead in their offices. The verdict in May 1979 is voluntary manslaughter rather than murder, and the public reaction to it turns into a riot at City Hall.

Held in order, the story shows how a political dispute about who would hold a seat on the Board ended in murder, and why the response to the sentence was so intense: for many people the killings were an attack on an elected official, and the verdict seemed to treat that attack as less than murder.

The city's response

Dianne Feinstein, then president of the Board of Supervisors, announced the deaths to reporters and television cameras. She became acting mayor, and the Board soon chose her to serve out Moscone's term. That evening, thousands of people carrying candles walked from the Castro down Market Street to City Hall. The vigil was silent, and it was among the largest gatherings in the city's recent history.

Moscone was mourned as a mayor who had tried to bring neighborhood groups and minorities into city government. Milk was mourned as a leader who had given a community a voice in the city's politics. Their deaths remain among the most significant events in San Francisco's history, and City Hall, where it happened, is treated as a site of memory (San Francisco City Hall, the building).

The trial and the White Night riot

Dan White was tried in 1979 for the two killings. The jury convicted him not of murder but of voluntary manslaughter, and he received a sentence of seven years and eight months. The sentence was lenient by the standards of a double homicide, and it was widely seen as a sign of how the legal system treated gay victims and their community.

On the night the verdict was announced, May 21, 1979, thousands of protesters marched to City Hall. The demonstration turned into a riot, which became known as the White Night riot. Protesters set police cars on fire and broke windows at City Hall, and later that night police officers retaliated against patrons in the Castro. The photographs that Daniel Nicoletta took of the riot are preserved in the library's records of the period.

The episode shaped relations between the gay community and the city's police for years afterward. It also gave a generation of activists in the Castro a sense that their political power would have to be organized, because the system could not be counted on to protect it.

Legacy

Milk's legacy has grown, not shrunk. In 2009 he was posthumously awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom. His life has been the subject of books, a documentary and a feature film. In San Francisco his name is attached to civic places. The Library's collection of his papers and photographs is a resource for researchers, and the Castro neighborhood where he worked remains closely associated with him.

Moscone's name is attached to the Moscone Center, the convention complex in the South of Market district where the city hosts large conferences. There is some fitness in it: a mayor who tried to open the city's economy and public life to more people is remembered by a building where tens of thousands of visitors gather each year.

Timeline

Date Event
1972 Milk moves to San Francisco and opens a camera store in the Castro
1975 Moscone is elected mayor
November 1977 Milk is elected to the Board of Supervisors
1978 The Board passes the sexual-orientation ordinance, 11 to 1; Moscone signs it
November 1978 Voters reject the Briggs Initiative
November 10, 1978 Dan White resigns from the Board
November 27, 1978 White kills Moscone and Milk at City Hall
May 21, 1979 The verdict, and the White Night riot
2009 Milk is posthumously awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom

Where to learn more

The San Francisco Public Library's LGBTQIA center, in the Main Library at Civic Center, keeps Milk's papers and publishes background on his career. The Castro neighborhood, where his store stood, is described in Castro. How the Board of Supervisors works today, with its eleven districts, is explained in the eleven districts and what a supervisor does.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic