Guides
Ranked-choice voting on a San Francisco ballot
How ranked-choice voting works on a San Francisco ballot: ranking up to ten candidates, marking ovals, the practice ballot and how results reports come out.
When a San Francisco ballot lists several candidates for mayor, supervisor, city attorney or another local office, you are not asked to pick one. You are asked to rank them. The system is called ranked-choice voting, and voters approved it in 2002 and the city first used it in 2004. Its logic is simple, but a ballot marked the wrong way can lose votes, so it is worth knowing what the grid looks like and what happens to a ranking after you submit it.
What the ballot asks
For a local race using ranked-choice voting, the ballot is a grid. Candidates are listed down the side and choices run across the top: first choice, second choice, third choice, and so on. The department's voter pamphlet says voters may rank up to ten candidates in these races. You fill in one oval per column, for the candidate you want in that position.
The rules the grid implies are the ones to remember:
- Fill in one oval for each choice. One candidate for first choice, one for second, and so on.
- Do not mark the same candidate twice. A candidate can appear in only one column. If you mark the same name twice, the second mark is ignored.
- Do not mark two candidates in the same column. Overvoting a choice invalidates that ranking and anything below it.
- You do not have to use every column. It is fine to rank one candidate, three, or all ten. Ranking more candidates cannot hurt your first choice.
- Rank in order, without gaps. Fill the columns from the left so your choices are read exactly as you meant them.
Races that are not ranked-choice, such as state and federal contests and most ballot measures, use ordinary voting: one mark per contest, yes or no on measures. A single ballot card contains both kinds, and the instructions near each contest say which applies.
How the count works
The department tabulates ranked-choice races in rounds. In the first round, every ballot counts for its first choice. If a candidate has a majority of the continuing ballots, the race is over. If no one does, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated, and each ballot that listed that candidate first moves to its next choice that is still in the race. The process repeats until a candidate has a majority. For a multi-seat or special contest the department publishes the rules for that contest.
Two consequences follow from the rounds:
- Your second choice matters only if your first choice is eliminated. It is never counted against your first choice.
- A ballot is exhausted when all of its ranked candidates have been eliminated. It stops counting at that point; it is not discarded earlier, and it counted in every earlier round.
Because every round is based on the ballots cast, the final tally shows each candidate's total in each round, not just a single percentage.
Practice ballot
The Department of Elections hosts a practice ranked-choice ballot on its website, so you can try the grid with sample candidates before you vote. The department's voter pamphlet and sf.gov pages point to it. If you will be voting for the first time, or if you are used to a one-vote system, try the sample once.
Overvotes, undervotes and mistakes
A mistake does not necessarily invalidate the ballot. If you mark more than one candidate in the same column, that column and the choices after it can be ignored, but earlier choices stand. If you make a bigger mistake, request a replacement ballot at the City Hall Voting Center or a polling place; see How to vote in San Francisco for the places and hours. When voting by mail, you can ask for a replacement ballot too.
How results come out
On election night the department posts preliminary results in a series of reports. Its published reporting timelines say that some of the reports include round-by-round ranked-choice results and others show only first-choice totals. That pattern explains why a race can look settled in the early evening and then shift in the later reports. After that, additional ballots are counted, and the department posts updated reports and, afterward, the full results, including ranked-choice details in PDF and spreadsheet form.
Read a results report in this order:
- The first-choice totals, which show who is ahead before any transfers.
- The round-by-round table, which shows each elimination and where its ballots went.
- The final round, which shows each remaining candidate's total and the majority needed.
Late-counted ballots matter. A race with a thin margin can move as the remaining ballots, including mail ballots that arrive after Election Day, are added and the rounds are recalculated. Official results are certified after the count, according to the schedule published for each election.
Why San Francisco ranks candidates
Supporters say ranking removes the need for a separate runoff and lets voters back a long-shot first choice without wasting the vote. Critics say the grid can be confusing, that ballots can be exhausted and that results take longer to report. Both arguments have been part of the local debate since voters adopted the system. How to vote in San Francisco covers the practical steps from registration to the return of the ballot.
Quick reference
- Local ranked-choice contests: rank up to ten candidates.
- One oval per column, one candidate per column.
- Your second choice cannot hurt your first.
- A ballot is counted in every round until all its choices are eliminated.
- Practice ballot: on the Department of Elections website.
- Questions: the Department of Elections, 415-558-6100, City Hall Room 48.